I suspect that any book that takes place on the English moors and has a smidgeon of romance in it runs the risk of being compared to Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte. Havencross by Julie Daines, because the moors feature prominently in its setting and  is a romance, could be compared to that classic book, but I think such a comparison would be inaccurate. To me, it was a combination of Blackmoore by Julianne Donaldson (a book most definitely compared to Wuthering Heights) and the Dark is Rising series by Susan Cooper. Though the latter books involve ancient magic and younger characters, I believe they share a strong sense of mystery and adventure with Havencross, traits which make it a stand-out in the regency romance genre. And its resemblance to Blackmoore lies in the charm of a main character who thinks she will never marry, but whose expectations of life are turned topsy-turvy by circumstances she could never have foreseen. Indeed, Havencross is a romance in the most charming of ways, mixed with surprising twists of intrigue and suspense.

What Havencross is About

Elaine Cardinham, the main character, and her parents are forced to return to their country home in Cornwall for refuge when a shocking scandal involving her father spreads through London society. But Havencross reminds her of the mysterious disappearance of her brother and a marriage proposal she spurned, both five years ago. There, she runs into the man who offered his hand, Gareth Kemp, and also, surprisingly, into a man who has followed her from London to offer her his hand now. He’s an earl, and she accepts without hesitation so as to escape her circumstances, but finds that Gareth never stopped loving her and that she really doesn’t know her fionce at all. They’re both distracted by dangerous and mysterious smugglers plaguing the Cornish coast, killing neighbors and others more and more frequently. As Elaine attempts to run from her past, she ventures ever closer to a dangerous truth—and finds that Gareth may be the only one who can save her from a deadly finish.

Why I Liked Havencross

There are a couple of elements that make Havencross more than just a romance or a mystery:

  • The fact that the story develops against the foil of Elaine’s and Gareth’s shared past—his failed proposal and their friendship before that—strengthens it and gives it flavor. Their shared recollections of wandering the moors with her brother, John, who was Gareth’s best friend, provides an emotional depth that I savored.
  • At a few key points, Elaine is led into some of the caves that pock the coast by a mysterious women who wears a circlet on her head. Elaine thinks she might be King Arthur’s Guinevere, since there are ruins nearby rumored to have been inhabited by the couple. This is where the connection to the Dark is Rising series comes in for me, as it is set in Cornwall as well and involves striving against certain evils. Elaine’s encounters with the mysterious woman pose questions that prowl around the reader’s brain for the duration of the novel, and help to provide critical clues that lead to the answers of other questions.

Who Would Like Havencross

Maybe it’s obvious, but anyone who loves works by Jane Austen, the Bronte sisters, Julianne Donaldson, Sarah M. Eden, or Susan Cooper would love Havencross.


Comment here or on Twitter if you’ve read this book or would like to read it, and I’ll enter you into a drawing for a copy of Havencross, signed by Julie Daines! Drawing will end at 11:59 p.m. August 19th.

1 Comment

  1. Book Reviews: Willowkeep and Winner's Curse - on August 6, 2018 at 3:26 am

    […] who likes Jane Austen’s works or those of the Bronte sisters, as will those who enjoyed Havencross, also by Julie Daines, or Shades of Milk and Honey by Mary Robinette […]

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply